Insights
SB 54 Is in Effect: What California's New Packaging Law Means for Your Business
August 26, 2026
Wilson Elser’s Intellectual Property & Technology Practice attorneys work with clients from start-ups to multinational corporations across all industries on virtually every kind of intellectual property matter. Clients benefit from our depth of related knowledge and ability to draw on the vast resources of a national network of offices comprising more than 1,400 attorneys.
For nearly 50 years, we have compiled an enviable record of success in maintaining, enforcing and protecting intellectual property in state, federal and international jurisdictions in these disciplines:
Art law intersects with a variety of disciplines, including intellectual property; commercial contracts; art-based financing; antitrust; bankruptcy, creditors’ rights and security interests; gifts, acquisitions, dispositions and liens; tax and estate planning; and litigation. Drawing on collective decades of related experience, Wilson Elser attorneys provide reliable legal counsel to virtually all participants in the creation, licensing, sale, lending, gifting, merchandising and display of art. Our clients include artists, collectors and buyers, sellers, insurers, gallerists and dealers, consultants, auction houses and museums.
We are familiar with applicable statutes and codes and skilled at safeguarding and protecting valuable creative assets. We also work “cross practice” with colleagues throughout the broader firm to address a range of issues.
Our related work:
Wilson Elser’s copyright practice is multifaceted, involving areas as diverse as literary and theatrical works, musical compositions, software, luxury goods, apparel, consumer products, and sales and instructional manuals.
Our related work:
Wilson Elser’s multidisciplinary Data Use & AI Governance attorneys partner with clients to develop, implement, and defend robust AI risk management programs that meet evolving legislative mandates and stakeholder expectations. Leveraging deep experience in intellectual property, technology, cybersecurity, employment, product liability, and class-action defense, we routinely counsel boards, business owners, product managers, and in-house counsel on how best to translate emerging AI statutes, standards, and risk management frameworks into practical policies and controls to satisfy regulators, investors, and consumers.
Our national platform and extensive network of specialists position us to guide proactive compliance initiatives from inception and to respond quickly when disputes arise. Indeed, team attorneys bring a proven record of success defending complex, high-stakes AI-related claims across industries and jurisdictions.
Our integrated capabilities include:
As business converges on a borderless online environment, our practice attorneys adapt and remain at the forefront of the developing law. We have substantial experience in multimedia law, including the representation of web-based clients, product developers and creative content owners. We assist companies with developing a compliant online presence in e-commerce and social media and protect clients who are attacked for internet-related activity.
Our related work:
As intellectual property plays an increasingly pivotal role in the entertainment and sports industries, our practice attorneys represent a broad spectrum of clients in areas such as fashion, photography, film, stage, television, sports and publishing.
Our related work:
When all other remedies have been exhausted, litigation is a route available to businesses to protect and defend their intellectual property rights. As the preeminent defense litigation firm in the United States, Wilson Elser seeks to achieve early and successful dismissals of most cases. We nonetheless will escalate matters to trial and appellate courts when it best serves our clients’ objectives.
Our related work:
Our patent practice comprises attorneys with broad-based scientific backgrounds who are admitted to practice before the USPTO’s patent bar. The team can staff patent matters appropriately, deploying attorneys with experience in biological, chemical, mechanical and computer sciences. From patent counseling to prosecution and enforcement or defense, our team preserves the rights of our clients.
Our related work:
We are well-versed in advising businesses on compliance risks and helping build compliance programs and systems. We understand that each organization is unique and so are its costs of doing business. Drawing on years of related experience, our team collaborates with clients’ stakeholders within the C-suite and in Legal, Marketing, Customer Service and IT departments in developing consumer privacy compliance programs from the ground up or refining and strengthening those that exist. We establish “turnkey” solutions for businesses, including scripts and workflows to assist in processing consumers’ privacy rights requests, such as Data Subject Access Requests (DSARs). To the extent that clients require our involvement once systems are in place, we are pleased to provide required trainings, audit compliance, and assistance in conducting data protection impact assessments and updating privacy notices as developing regulations require.
Our related work:
Our Intellectual Property & Technology practice attorneys keep pace with advancements in all aspects of technology services. We understand the substance and subtleties of hardware and software products that can be especially valuable to their owners and especially vulnerable to outside entities. We assist clients with technology transactions and technology development and distribution deals; protect technology brands; and strategically advise on commercialization in a wide range of technology sectors. With the emergence of the Internet of Things and the transition to a borderless online environment, a position at the forefront of related developments is critical. We assist clients across a wide spectrum of related services.
Investing in name and brand recognition often equates to increased profits and asset growth. Wilson Elser assists in obtaining, securing, maintaining and enforcing trademark rights for clients worldwide. We also defend clients sued for trademark-related issues.
Our related work:
Wilson Elser’s Intellectual Property & Technology Practice attorneys work with clients from start-ups to multinational corporations across all industries on virtually every kind of intellectual property matter. Clients benefit from our depth of related knowledge and ability to draw on the vast resources of a national network of offices comprising more than 1,400 attorneys.
For nearly 50 years, we have compiled an enviable record of success in maintaining, enforcing and protecting intellectual property in state, federal and international jurisdictions in these disciplines:
Sean M. Monks (Partner-San Diego, CA), Richard Bortnick (Of Counsel-Philadelphia, PA), and Chelsea Gaudet (Associate-San Diego, CA) achieved dismissal with prejudice in the U.S. District Court, Central District of California on behalf of their client, a beauty product manufacturer, in a federal action alleging copyright infringement, unfair competition, and violations of the Lanham Act. The plaintiff, a leading manufacturer of beauty products and accessories, alleged that the client’s advertising for its solid shampoo and conditioner products was confusingly similar to the plaintiff’s advertising. Both companies market solid shampoo and conditioner products online, including through Amazon. The plaintiff’s advertisements feature the products placed on top of their packaging, with images of the products’ ingredients scattered below on the package. The plaintiff alleged that our client’s advertisements similarly depicted its products and ingredients and that the client’s packaging used wording in the same order, with the same words appearing in larger font. The plaintiff further alleged that the client’s products were not packaged as depicted in its advertisements and that the advertising was designed to confuse consumers into believing the products were offered by the plaintiff or purchasing the client’s products when they intended to purchase the plaintiff’s products.
The Wilson Elser team challenged the sufficiency of the complaint. The court agreed with its argument that the plaintiff failed to plausibly allege a “false statement of fact” concerning the client’s products or another’s products and, therefore, failed to state a false advertising claim under the Lanham Act. The court also concurred with the team’s argument that the copyright claims must be dismissed, agreeing that the similarities fell within a “thin” range of the copyright protection spectrum. In particular, the court agreed that the arrangement of the shampoo and conditioner products and their ingredients constituted an unprotectable idea or concept and that, although certain individual elements appeared similar, “none of these elements is subject to copyright protection when viewed in isolation.” Finally, because the first two claims failed, the court dismissed the unfair competition claim for lack of an underlying unlawful act. The plaintiff did not amend its complaint, resulting in dismissal with prejudice.
Sean M. Monks, Richard J. Bortnick and Chelsea J. Gaudet
Sarah Fink (Of Counsel-Long Island, NY) and Wisaal Jahangir (Associate-New York, NY) secured a favorable resolution in the U.S. District Court, Eastern District of New York, successfully settling a federal copyright infringement action against their high-end luxury hotel client that had gone bankrupt since the alleged violation. The plaintiff, a photographer, sought relief under the U.S. Copyright Act, including actual damages and disgorgement of profits (or, in the alternative, statutory damages per alleged infringement), injunctive relief, litigation costs and attorneys’ fees, and pre-judgment interest. Statutory damages under the Act can reach up to $30,000 per work for non-willful infringement and up to $150,000 per work for willful infringement. Sarah and Wisaal’s primary argument was that the plaintiff could not show any profits from the violation, given that the hotel went out of business, leveraging the fact that statutory damages generally approximate actual damages, and that damages in copyright cases include profits to the defendant. Arguing that the plaintiff’s initial demand of $40,000 was therefore unreasonable, Wilson Elser resolved the matter for $10,000, closing the case on terms advantageous to the client.
Sarah Fink and Wisaal Jahangir
Wilson Elser’s Intellectual Property & Technology Practice attorneys work with clients from start-ups to multinational corporations across all industries on virtually every kind of intellectual property matter. Clients benefit from our depth of related knowledge and ability to draw on the vast resources of a national network of offices comprising more than 1,400 attorneys.
For nearly 50 years, we have compiled an enviable record of success in maintaining, enforcing and protecting intellectual property in state, federal and international jurisdictions in these disciplines: