Nathan Lefko (Associate-Washington, DC) and Kevin Farrell (Partner-Washington, DC) secured declaratory relief in the Circuit Court of Montgomery County, Maryland, for Wilson Elser’s client, a homeowners association, in a dispute over the association's architectural review authority.

The association denied approval for a walkway installed by a homeowner. The homeowner filed suit contesting that determination, claiming the denial rested on an arbitrary reading of the community's Architectural Guidelines. In his briefing to the court, Nate demonstrated that the association's decision reflected a reasoned application of the HOA’s governing documents. The association also contended that the business judgment rule protected its decision. Under this principle, courts defer to a community association's good-faith decisions and may not second-guess those decisions without evidence of bad faith or fraud. 

After extensive oral argument, the court granted the association's cross-motion for summary judgment and denied the homeowner's motion. The court held that the association's determination is protected by the business judgment rule and ordered the walkway removed within 60 days. The ruling confirms that an association acting in good faith may enforce its governing documents without undue interference from the courts. It also protects the shared standards on which homeowners rely and supports consistent architectural review across the community.