Mathew Ross (Partner-White Plains, NY) and Jazmin Williams (Associate-White Plains, NY) obtained summary judgment and dismissal of a negligence action in the Richmond County Supreme Court, New York, on behalf of Wilson Elser’s grocery store client. The plaintiff claimed she arrived at the client’s store, retrieved a shopping cart (she later testified that the cart was in good working condition at that time), and shopped throughout the store without issue, but that the cart suddenly broke as she was paying for her items, causing her injuries. Throughout the litigation, plaintiff’s counsel maintained his client would not settle for under $250,000.
Mat and Jazmin moved for summary judgment, arguing that the accident was unexpected; there was no evidence of a defect that could have been discovered before the accident; and that the client’s carts were routinely inspected throughout the day such that if any observable defect existed, the cart would have been removed from service. They further argued that the plaintiff could not rely on the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur because she controlled the subject shopping cart at the time of the accident.
In opposition, the plaintiff argued that no written record of shopping cart inspections existed and that no evidence showed when the subject shopping cart was last inspected, or whether it was ever inspected at all. At oral argument, Jazmin emphasized that a designated employee inspected the store’s 60–90 shopping carts daily, the store hadn’t received any complaints of defective cart baskets or reports of similar accidents, and that the plaintiff herself had observed the cart to be in good condition before using it without incident for more than 20 minutes.
The court agreed that the routine inspections, coupled with the absence of prior similar accidents or complaints, established that the client lacked notice of any defect, notwithstanding the lack of specific inspection records. The court granted summary judgment and dismissed the complaint in its entirety.