News Briefs
Super Lawyers Names Five from Wilson Elser to 2025 Florida Super Lawyers and Rising Stars Lists
June 27, 2025
Danielle T. Gauer (Of Counsel-Miami, FL), Maria Papasakelariou (Associate-Miami, FL) and Brian Del Gatto (Partner-Phoenix, AZ) secured a voluntary dismissal on behalf of a Canadian insurance carrier doing business out of Nova Scotia, Canada. The plaintiff, a resident of Nova Scotia and the insured, sought uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage related to an accident that occurred in Florida against a policy with $1+ million in potential benefits. The team filed a motion to quash service of process and a motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction and forum non conveniens, arguing that the plaintiff inappropriately served the insurance company by attempting to serve a completely unrelated U.S. entity. The application of the law of Nova Scotia by a court located in the province, coupled with the fact that all potential witnesses are Canadian and the evidence is located in the province, makes Nova Scotia the more appropriate forum for this dispute. The team proved that the Canadian company was in fact completely separate from the U.S. insurer of a similar name. The plaintiff’s response to our motion tried to make the argument that the affidavit of the insurance adjuster was not legally sufficient under the law as the adjuster did not have personal knowledge of the matter. Furthermore, the plaintiff argued that Canada is not an adequate alternative forum because the insurance carrier should step into the shoes of the owner of the uninsured or underinsured vehicle. However, the cases cited by the plaintiff failed to involve a non-U.S. or foreign insurance carrier. Finally, on the eve before the hearing, the plaintiff’s counsel filed a notice dismissing our client. This continues our string of success in protecting our Canadian clients from being hauled into courts like Florida without proper grounds.
Danielle T. Gauer, Maria Papasakelariou and Brian Del Gatto