Press Releases
Wilson Elser Elevates 34 to Partnership in 2025
January 8, 2025
Melinda Flecker (Partner-Long Island, NY) and Tal Cushmaro (Partner-White Plains, NY) have secured a unanimous defense verdict on behalf of the firm’s client, Uber Technologies, Inc (Uber), in a motor vehicle accident case tried in Supreme Court, Kings County, New York. The plaintiff alleged she was injured in a two-vehicle collision involving a co-defendant driver and claimed that Uber was vicariously liable for the driver’s alleged negligence. She contended that the driver was Uber’s employee because he was using the Uber App and transporting a passenger obtained through the platform at the time of the accident. Melinda and Tal successfully defended the case by demonstrating, through evidence elicited during the plaintiff’s case-in-chief, that the driver was an independent contractor, not an employee. The trial’s liability phase spanned three weeks, including seven days of jury selection, extensive motion practice, and five days of testimony. After deliberating for approximately 30 minutes, the jury concluded that although the driver was negligent, Uber was not liable for his conduct because he was not its employee.
Tal Z. Cushmaro and Melinda Flecker
Melinda Flecker (Of Counsel-Long Island, NY) and Andreia Bento (Associate-Long Island, NY) prevailed on a Rule 33 dispositive motion in a matter arbitrated by the American Arbitration Association. The plaintiff in this case filed a lawsuit following an automobile accident alleging various negligence claims based on theories of agency/ control, negligent hiring/ retention, and ownership. The Arbitrator found that our global technology company client was not vicariously liable for the actions of the driver because he was an independent contractor and not an employee, and dismissed the matter with prejudice. This win represents another solid addition to the growing list of New York precedents favoring Wilson Elser’s clients.
Melinda Flecker and Andreia L. Bento