Insights
Florida Punitive Damages Amendments Now Subject to Interlocutory Appeal
January 7, 2022
Obtained summary judgment on behalf of pain pump manufacturer on federal preemption grounds pursuant to the Medical Device Amendments to the Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act and presented oral argument to the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals in support of the order. The Eleventh Circuit affirmed the summary judgment order.
Successfully defended medical device manufacturer’s technician on claims of negligence with respect to programming of a neurostimulator.
Obtained dismissal of medical device action based on the plaintiff’s failure to comply with the statute of limitations.
Obtained dismissal of product liability action against a power tool manufacturer following a motion to strike plaintiff’s expert on Daubert grounds.
Successfully negotiated settlements of asbestos and benzene cases on behalf of a product manufacturer.
Successfully negotiated permanent injunctions in trademark violation actions involving improper use of trade dress and product replicas.
Obtained summary judgment on behalf of pain pump manufacturer on federal preemption grounds pursuant to the Medical Device Amendments to the Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act and presented oral argument to the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals in support of the order. The Eleventh Circuit affirmed the summary judgment order.
Successfully defended medical device manufacturer’s technician on claims of negligence with respect to programming of a neurostimulator.
Obtained dismissal of medical device action based on the plaintiff’s failure to comply with the statute of limitations.
Obtained dismissal of product liability action against a power tool manufacturer following a motion to strike plaintiff’s expert on Daubert grounds.
Successfully negotiated settlements of asbestos and benzene cases on behalf of a product manufacturer.
Successfully negotiated permanent injunctions in trademark violation actions involving improper use of trade dress and product replicas.
Jacqueline Bertelsen (Of Counsel-Orlando) Noelle Sheehan (Partner-Orlando) and Melissa Krepps (Of Counsel-Orlando) successfully had their summary judgment victory upheld in the Florida Sixth Circuit Court of Appeal in a nursing home negligence and wrongful death lawsuit. Noelle and Melissa relied on provisions of an asset purchase agreement to prevail on their motion for summary judgment. Following the entry of summary judgment, the plaintiff moved for rehearing. Noelle and Melissa brought in Jacqueline Bertelsen from the firm’s Appellate Practice group to assist. Jacqueline opposed the motion for rehearing as untimely, and the trial court agreed. The plaintiff then appealed to Florida’s Sixth District. The Sixth District issued an Order to the plaintiff to show cause as to why the appeal should not be dismissed as untimely. The plaintiff argued that the untimely appeal was due to counsel’s excusable neglect. Jacqueline worked with Noelle to prepare a comprehensive response brief that demonstrated the legal insufficiency of the plaintiff’s brief and revealed factual inconsistencies between the plaintiff’s argument and the record. As a result, the Sixth District dismissed the appeal and upheld summary judgment for our client. This victory demonstrates how Wilson Elser’s attorneys work seamlessly across practice areas to deliver successful client outcomes.
Jacqueline M. Bertelsen, Noelle K. Sheehan and Melissa D. Krepps
Noelle Sheehan (Partner-Orlando, FL) and Melissa Krepps (Of Counsel-Orlando, FL) secured summary judgment in a nursing home negligence lawsuit involving claims brought by the estate of a former patient. The plaintiff alleged negligence related to care provided at our client’s facility. However, through diligent investigation and presentation of undisputed material facts, Noelle and Melissa demonstrated that our client neither owned nor operated the facility during the patient’s residency and had no involvement in his care or treatment. The facility was acquired by our client after his discharge, and the asset purchase agreement expressly excluded any liabilities for prior residents’ claims. The Circuit Court of the Tenth Judicial Circuit in and for Polk County, Florida, agreed with our position, finding that the defendant owed no duty to the estate and could not be held liable for any alleged negligence. As a result, summary judgment was granted in favor of our client, bringing a successful resolution to a case that had been active for several years.
Noelle K. Sheehan and Melissa D. Krepps