Client Wins

New York Team Achieves Unanimous Defense Verdict in High-Exposure Labor Law Trial

Thomas Comer (Partner, New York), Thomas O’Connor (Associate, White Plains), and Judy Selmeci (Partner, New York), obtained a complete defense verdict on behalf of the client in Supreme Court, Nassau County before the Hon. Catherine Rizzo. The jury unanimously found that the client bore no liability in connection with plaintiff’s claimed Labor Law accident. Plaintiff, a 24-year-old demolition laborer at the time of the alleged incident, claimed that he sustained injuries as a result of a fall from a scaffold while performing interior demolition work. He alleged significant orthopedic injuries, including to his knee, spine, and shoulder, and underwent multiple surgical procedures, including a two-level lumbar laminectomy, a single-level cervical fusion, and a left shoulder arthroscopy. He further claimed total disability, with over $1,000,000 in alleged future lost wages. Plaintiff’s theory as to the client was not based on any actual involvement in the work, but on an effort to characterize the client as a “contractor” or statutory agent based largely on a permit issued in its name. The defense focused on a clear and targeted strategy: establishing that the client had no authority to direct, supervise, or control the injury-producing work. The evidence showed that the client did not perform work at the site, did not retain plaintiff or any subcontractors, did not receive payment, and had no role in how the work was carried out. Instead, the work was performed independently by others, without the client’s knowledge or involvement. During the charge conference, the team secured modified jury instructions to both PJI 2:216 and 2:217. Over opposition, the Court agreed to instruct the jury that it must first determine whether the client had the authority to supervise, direct, or control the work before considering any potential Labor Law liability. That framework was reinforced in the verdict sheet, which required the jury to address this threshold issue at the outset. At trial, the defense also highlighted significant credibility issues in plaintiff’s account, including his admission that he told medical providers he was injured in a bicycle accident. Through cross-examination and the testimony of a neutral medical witness, the defense established that plaintiff offered multiple, inconsistent explanations for this discrepancy. Following nearly four hours of deliberations, the jury returned a unanimous defense verdict, with the jury assigning 0% liability to the client.

Thomas W. Comer, Thomas C. O'Connor and Judy C. Selmeci

Margolis and O’Connor Secure Pre-Answer Dismissal in Residential Habitability Action

Thomas O’Connor (Associate-White Plains, NY) and Bernice E. Margolis (Partner-White Plains, NY) secured pre-answer dismissal of all claims in the Supreme Court, New York County​, on behalf of Wilson Elser’s property owner clients in a residential habitability action. The plaintiff, a long-term occupant of a New York City loft unit, alleged that our clients failed to maintain the premises and engaged in a coordinated effort to force her out to increase rent. The complaint cataloged a wide range of alleged deficient building conditions, including unsafe stairways, pest infestations, structural defects, lack of heat and hot water, exposed wiring, and mold. The plaintiff further claimed to have suffered significant emotional and physical injuries, including panic attacks, depression, and gastrointestinal distress. Based on these allegations, the plaintiff advanced numerous causes of action sounding in negligence, premises liability, breach of the warranty of habitability, breach of quiet enjoyment, private nuisance, constructive eviction, and intentional and negligent infliction of emotional distress, seeking substantial compensatory and punitive damages.

Recognizing all claims were either time-barred or improperly pled, Tom and Bernice filed a pre-answer motion to dismiss the plaintiff’s complaint on multiple, independent grounds. Central to their motion was the argument that the plaintiff’s claims concerning building conditions, habitability, and Loft Law compliance fell within the primary jurisdiction of the New York City Loft Board, and that the plaintiff’s failure to exhaust administrative remedies barred the action. The motion further established that the emotional distress claims were time-barred, that the plaintiff’s attempt to plead a Penal Law violation failed as a matter of law for lack of a private right of action, and the claims against the individual defendants were legally deficient.

In response, the plaintiff did not meaningfully engage with the merits of Wilson Elser’s motion, instead attempting to sidestep dismissal by filing successive amended complaints without leave of court, in an effort to moot the motion. In their reply, Tom and Bernice squarely addressed and neutralized this tactic. They demonstrated that the filings were procedurally improper, contravened the Court’s directives, and failed to cure any substantive defects, emphasizing that the plaintiff’s latest pleading was merely a “difference without distinction.”

The Court adopted our position in full, holding that the plaintiff failed to substantively oppose the motion, that the unauthorized amended pleading was a nullity, and that the plaintiff’s failure to address the arguments made on behalf of our clients constituted abandonment of her claims. The Court dismissed the complaint in its entirety.

Bernice E. Margolis and Thomas C. O'Connor

Margolis, O’Connor, and Stopnik Secure Discontinuance in Complex Declaratory Judgment Action Through Strategic Motion Practice

​Bernice E. Margolis (Partner-White Plains), Thomas O’Connor (Associate-White Plains), and Scott Stopnik (Partner-White Plains) successfully represented an insurance and bonding company – securing a discontinuance and the court’s endorsement of their position – after being substituted in as counsel in a seven-year running declaratory judgment action pending in the New York Supreme Court, New York County.  After reviewing years of inherited filings, Bernice, Tom, and Scott identified a critical procedural defect that had gone unnoticed for years: the plaintiffs were pursuing identical breach of contract claims in both the declaratory judgment action and the underlying liability action. They moved to dismiss under CPLR § 3211(a)(4), demonstrating that the actions involved the same parties, claims, and relief, and that the underlying action had already reached the summary judgment stage, and that the plaintiffs’ claims against our client were fully addressed in that action.

Opposing counsel later conceded they had no basis to resist dismissal and had included the client in the declaratory judgment action merely to obtain additional discovery. The White Plains team declined to delay the matter and instead proposed that the plaintiffs execute a Stipulation of Discontinuance as to the client in exchange for the withdrawal of the motion. At the subsequent appearance, the judge adopted this approach.

Through focused review and strategic motion practice, Wilson Elser extricated the client from a protracted action without further discovery, deposition activity, or costly litigation, eliminating duplicate exposure and streamlining related proceedings.

Bernice E. Margolis, Thomas C. O'Connor and Scott H. Stopnik

Privacy Settings