Client Wins

Semlies & Burkova Secure Dismissal of Case Based on COVID-19 Immunity Grounds

Lori Semlies (Partner-White Plains, NY) and Kristyna Burkova (Associate-New York, NY) were successful on a motion to dismiss the complaint on behalf of our clients, a hospital and physician, based on COVID-19 immunity grounds, specifically on EDTPA and PREP Act immunities. Lori and Kristyna moved to dismiss at the close of discovery after more than three years of litigation. The 71-year-old plaintiff was transferred to our client hospital with a COVID-19 diagnosis, strep mitis bacteremia, spinal osteomyelitis at C2-C3 and L3-L4, multi-focal pneumonia, and pulmonary edema. Upon admission, he received all indicated care, and when he was stable enough, he was transferred to Mount Sinai Hospital for evaluation for an aortic valve replacement. His  injuries healed completely within three months of discharge. When the plaintiff filed suit, Lori and Kristyna submitted a geriatric expert affirmation in support, as well as expert affirmation of a board-certified pulmonary and critical care physician, who was a director of the medical ICU during the pandemic and who detailed the impact of the pandemic on the care at the time of plaintiff’s admission. Before filing his opposition, plaintiff cross-moved to amend the pleadings to add a gross negligence cause of action in an obvious attempt to circumvent the immunities. The Court granted our motion pursuant to the immunities afforded by the EDTPA and PREP Act and denied plaintiff’s cross-motion for leave to amend the complaint for failure to present a meritorious cause of action. In the decision, following its prior decisions in Kalogiannis and Gerber, the court noted that plaintiff’s claims fall squarely within the immunity. 

Lori Rosen Semlies and Kristyna Burkova

Gregory, Humphries, and Burkova Secure Defense Verdict in Informed Consent Case

New York City partners Robin Gregory and Ashley Humphries and associate Kristyna Burkova obtained a defense verdict in a medical malpractice case after a two-week trial in Supreme Court, New York County. This case involved then 66-year-old plaintiff with a gastrointestinal stromal tumor (GIST), who underwent a laparoscopic wedge resection. Postoperatively, he developed an obstruction and gastroparesis. The plaintiff claimed that the surgeon failed to advise him of the complications of the surgery and that a benign lesion may have been treated with an alternative open procedure, or watchful waiting. The plaintiff also claimed permanent gastrointestinal issues, including years of vomiting and disability. The defense argued that the only accepted reasonable treatment for plaintiff’s 6 cm GIST was surgical excision and that there were no alternatives. Further, the team argued that the plaintiff was fully informed, including drawings that were made at the surgeon’s office, and that he suffered well-recognized complications of gastric surgery. The plaintiff’s demand before trial was $1.5 million. The court dismissed all claims other than informed consent. The jury found that the plaintiff was appropriately informed, and the case resulted in a defense verdict within one hour after submission to the jury for deliberation. 

Robin N. Gregory, Ashley V. Humphries and Kristyna Burkova

Burkova and Semlies Secure Dismissal Due to Repeated IME No Show

Kristyna Burkova (Associate-New York, NY) and Lori Semlies (Partner-New York, NY) were successful with a motion to dismiss the complaint against our client, New York Presbyterian Queens Hospital (NYPQ), for failure to appear for an independent medical examination (IME). The case involved a premature twin baby who sustained an IV infiltration on her left ankle in the NICU at NYPQ, which was treated in the burn unit at New York Presbyterian – Weill Cornell for one week and remained in the NICU for another month due to issues related to her respiratory function and ability to adequately feed. About two months after the infant’s discharge home, her left ankle wound was noted as a healed scar by her pediatrician and the infant did not appear to have any continued issues, nor did her parents seek additional treatment. When the plaintiff claimed scarring, open wound, deformity, bleeding, swelling, limited range of motion and conscious pain and suffering, Krystina and Lori designated a plastic surgery IME. The plaintiff did not object to the designation and was ordered to undergo the IME in two consecutive compliance conference orders. Despite plaintiff’s repeated failure to appear for the IME (as well as failure to provide other paper discovery), and despite our 11 good faith correspondences, the court gave plaintiff one last chance. Krystina and Lori filed a motion to dismiss the day after the third deadline passed. Hon. Tracy Catapano-Fox of the Queens County Supreme Court granted the motion noting that “[while] dismissal is a drastic remedy, plaintiff’s actions and inactions demonstrate willful and contumacious behavior that warrants dismissal under CPLR §3126.”  

Kristyna Burkova and Lori Rosen Semlies

Privacy Settings
Your Privacy Choices
We value your privacy. Under privacy laws in your jurisdiction, you have the right to control how your personal information is used, including the right to opt out of the “sale” or “sharing” of your personal information for cross-context behavioral advertising. You may also limit the use of your sensitive personal information.

Below, you can review and adjust your cookie and data sharing preferences. For more information about how we use your data, please see our Privacy Policy.

Your Rights and Choices

Opt Out of Sale or Sharing: You may opt out of the sale or sharing of your personal information for advertising and analytics purposes by turning off Advertising & Targeting Cookies. We will honor your choice and will not sell or share your personal information for these purposes unless you enable these cookies again. Wilson Elser does not sell or share personal information in any other manner.

Limit Use of Sensitive Personal Information: If we collect sensitive personal information, you may limit its use to only what is necessary to provide requested services by adjusting your preferences here. Please contact privacy@wilsonelser.com with any questions.

Global Privacy Control: We honor browser-based opt-out signals, such as the Global Privacy Control (GPC). If we detect such a signal, your opt-out preference will be automatically applied.

These cookies are essential for the website to function and cannot be switched off in our systems. They are usually set in response to actions made by you, such as setting your privacy preferences, logging in, or filling in forms.

These cookies enable the website to provide enhanced functionality and personalization. If you do not allow these cookies, some or all of these services may not function properly.

These cookies allow us to count visits and traffic sources so we can measure and improve the performance of our site. They may be set through our site by us or our analytics partners to understand your interests and deliver more relevant content to you. If you do not allow these cookies, we will not know when you have visited our site